Germany’s Declining Economy: The Sick Man of Europe Once Again

A Glimpse at Germany’s Economic History

The year 2024 was marked yet again with tough parkings for Germany, a country that once relished the title of being a strong European economy owing to its key position in trading. With its characteristic “social market economic model,” Germany’s economy incorporates a free-market-oriented capitalistic structure embedded with social policies to provide citizens with rights in terms of health, employment, job security, and pensions.

As the Second World War ended in 1948, many economies, including the Europeans, struggled with instability. Germany’s efficacious management of currency crises and its prudent economic policy particularly in its Western part helped revive the economic growth for the entire Europe. Thus, history reports a phenomenal financial growth in Germany from 1951–65. In the 1990s, the country started seeing ugly glimpses of economic downturns. However, it was able to retain a significant global trading economy owing to the export of transport, electrical, and chemical materials.

Reports on the Current Situation Germany’s Economy

In 2023, the year that placed Germany at the bottom of the world’s major economies for the first time, Germany’s economy contracted by as much as 0.3 percent. The slowest economic growth triggered energy crises, inflation, and business delays as well as the decline in consumption demand. As the analysts had predicted, 2024 proved no better for the German economy. The recession phase for the economy continued. Germany’s economic minister, Robert Habeck, declared a contraction of 0.2 percent in the German economy in 2024. In the Group of Seven (G7) countries, it is the only country that has been shrinking its economy for a second year in succession.

What contributed negatively to Germany, the sick man of Europe? How did the situation change from bleak to disastrous? As the world is forecasting 2025, what is there to hope for strengthening the German economy? To answer these questions, an understanding of the major reasons behind successive downturns in the German economy is needed. The following factors contributed to economic troubles for Germany:

The Offset by Pandemic Years

The COVID-19 pandemic worsened the health and economic conditions in various countries. In Europe, where many countries had a remarkably high fatality rate, German health performance was appreciable as the policies to restrict infections proved fruitful. However, the country paid a high price in terms of sluggish economic activity resulting in unemployment and worsening of the populace’s living standards.

After the pandemic years, when many activities returned to normal, the German economic downturns continued owing to structural issues and a lack of adaptability to the changing international business world.

Geopolitical Factors

1. Russia-Ukraine War and Energy Crises

The war between Russia and Ukraine, which escalated in February 2022, strongly impacted the energy balance in Germany. Until Ukraine was invaded, Germany could import energy at a moderate rate from Russia. The sharp increase in energy prices caused problems for Germany. Analysts report that after a period of the Russia-Ukraine war, the energy situation bettered. However, the situation remained the same for Germany owing to its structural factors. 

2. Slippery China-Germany Relations

Germany depends on China for global trade on some raw materials. On the other hand, China is a rival of Europe. So, Germany’s dependence on China is considered a critical relationship. Owing to the complexity of this relationship, the trade between the two had become imbalanced and weak in previous years. For example, the latest informational authorities from both sides acknowledge the underlying disagreements and mutually cooperative points.

Chinese mistreatment of the Uyghur minority, and in Hong Kong and Taiwan is concerning for Germany. On the Chinese side, the German laws are upsetting, which harden the operation of China’s 5G company Huawei. Despite these disagreements, they are willing to continue trade as China is Germans biggest trading partner. However, the European perception of China as a “systematic rival” is creating problems for Germany to balance the relationship.

3. Complex Germany-United States Relations

Previously, during Trump’s regime, Germany’s relations with America suffered. After Biden came into power, security and economic relations revived. After Russia invaded Ukraine, Germany was inclined towards the US for its energy sector in preference to its former partner Russia, as the US had reservations about Germany’s pipeline with Russia.

In terms of military grounds, both countries support Ukraine. Germany plays host to over 35 thousand US Army personnel as they plan to base long-range missiles in Germany by 2026. Pertaining to the economy, both nations are trading partners and have concerns about the impact of China’s geopolitics. However, as the US president-elect Donald Trump is set to hold his office on coming January, the US is likely to shift away from Ukraine support and economic cooperation with Germany. However, at present their economic cooperation is significant.

4. Economic Dynamics in the Eurozone

Being in the European Union, the economic activity in the Eurozone impacts Germany. Inflation and increased interest rates have further exacerbated Germany’s struggling economy. Therefore, German trade, corporate savings, and overall economic growth depend on the economic dynamics in the Eurozone. Thus, the strict economic policies in the Eurozone deeply impact Germany as the country is laced with structural issues.

Structural Challenges for Germany

The structural issues in Germany are multifold. Some of these are summarized below:

• The country lacks sufficient digital development as per the needs of the developed world.
• Germany faces problems in terms of demographics. The majority of the workforce is aging. This is likely to cause more workforce disruption in the coming years.
• Private consumption in the country is on the decline because of low economic growth and an increase in private savings.
• The dependency on energy is creating problems for Germany as the global geopolitical situation has changed, resulting in energy crises for the country. 
• Car production in the country is significantly slow, which has been the country’s pillar for the economy. This highlights the challenges faced by the automotive industry as high costs and competition from China.
• Transitioning to electric vehicles and shutting down nuclear power plants for a swift shift towards renewable sources is also creating disturbance for the country’s overall economy.

Latest Political Crisis in Germany

The coalition government in Germany has already collapsed owing to disagreements over financial matters and policies. The German chancellor has lost confidence vote and the country is on its way towards election in February 2025. Amidst such political crises, the important decision-making pertaining to economic management has been delayed. In such a critical time when the economy is already stagnating, such delays are lethal and have contributed to further downturns for the country such as high labor and taxes. Moreover, the German economy has yet to see how the new coalition government approaches economic crises.

The Road to Recovery for the Sick Man of Europe

The forecasts for 2025 are better for the “sick man of Europe.” It is anticipated that gross domestic product will increase by 1.1 percent, paving the way for a projected 1.6 percent growth rate in 2026. However, the realization of such forecasts requires structural changes and geopolitical and geoeconomic changes as reviewed by analysts. Additionally, the future of Germany’s economy depends on the elected government and its policies.

The following is a summary of key points to consider as presented by analysts on the German economy:

• The country’s energy policy needs consideration as energy dependency on Russia has backfired on Germany owing to the high prices.
• The China-Germany relationship is slippery, demanding Germany to direct its foreign policy.
• The trade dependence on the US might see more restrictions owing to the results of the 2024 US elections.
• The German strategies on technological integration and infrastructure need practicality. 
• The policies on population demographics also demand a shift as a major section of the German population has aged.
• The country needs a shift in car production policies which are inclining towards electric vehicles and facing China as a competitor, while the major section of the economy is suffering.

Conclusion

Germany is the Eurozone’s major economy. However, its growth remains weak for the second year in a row. Globally, the trade is experiencing slowdowns. The geopolitical situation after the Russia-Ukraine war has negatively impacted the country. However, geopolitical crises are strongly impacting Germany because of its structural complications.

The energy costs are on the rise in Germany as it depends on Russian gas and is shifting towards renewable energy sources whilst shutting down nuclear power plants. In the car production sector, the country is experiencing immense competition from China and inflation. Public investment, consumption, and digital integration have lowered, and the workforce is aging.

Moreover, the country’s coalition government collapsed, paving the way for delays in policies and projects. The forecasts for 2025 are relatively hopeful. However, given the current political instability in Germany and the world, its structural complications, and the victory of Donald Trump, many factors will likely impede Germany’s way to recovering and growing its economy in 2025.

---

If you want to submit your articles and/or research papers, please check the Submissions page.

The views and opinions expressed in this article/paper are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect the editorial position of Paradigm Shift.